The Wire

The world's greatest print and online music magazine. Independent since 1982

In Writing

The Mire: Tangents, threads and opinions from The Wire HQ

Collateral damage

Jennifer Lucy Allan

Kenneth Goldsmith's Epiphany in the May issue of the print zine is the first in a series of essays about digital cultures and their effect on the music industry: what they mean for listeners and creators, the change they bring about in cultural currencies and obsessions, and the moral and monetary issues surrounding freebies and filesharing.

The discussion continues in the current June issue with a response to Goldsmith's piece from ReR label head Chris Cutler. Both essays, and all forthcoming essays, will be published online. Traditionally, this goes against the rules of digital publishing: replicating content online for free devalues the print zine, meaning readers are less likely to shell out for the hard copy. In effect, we're filesharing our own content. So why are we doing it?

No other content from The Wire's printed page – bar our monthly listings – gets uploaded to the site (archive editorial content is drawn from back issues that are sold out). However, the subject matter of the essays by Goldsmith and Cutler demand that we make an exception. What's the point of an essay about the effect of the internet if we hold it back from the online communities that are part of the digital paradigm shift we're discussing?

Writing about the impact of new technologies on the economy of music too often boils down to one of two things: a new tech or digital sales pitch heralded as the saviour of the industry or (as is more often the case) its imminent demise. The reality is not so simple. The digital landscape is inherently fragmentary, meaning we're all looking on this scene from a different angle: what's destroyed one has often brought another success, and so keeping these essays within the confines of the magazine limits any hope of turning snapshots into a coherent picture.

In short, this is not a discussion that belongs on the printed page, but one that should be a part of the digital cultures it examines.

Tags: | | | | |


great piece - lots more of this please!

Good to hear. I think the Wire has improved dramatically in recent months, and it's largely down to this meta-thread around digital culture that's been running through the issues... looking forward to more calls and responses...

totally agree, and I was hoping you'll post it somewhere. I must say I agree with Mr. Cutler, as much as I believe music has to be free as well. The only thing to note is the balance between the two. I thing that it's for the benefit of the musician to giveaway stuff for free (and this is what I do in my monthly newsletter or through my bandcamp page), but also set a price tag on other 'items' so the audience will understand that music has a commercial value, be in one dollar or a hundred.

Anyway, good thing you posted the articles here, this is going to be an interesting multiple dialog.

Comments are closed for this article